A challenging text on Mary

Today (Nov. 21) in the Church’s calendar we celebrate the feast of the Presentation of the Virgin Mary in the Temple (this refers to when Mary was presented by her parents, not the Presentation of Jesus, which is celebrated February 2nd). The Gospel for the day is quite interesting, as it seems to contradict the devotion we have to Mary:

While Jesus was speaking to the crowds, his mother and his brothers appeared outside, wishing to speak with him. Someone told him, “Your mother and your brothers are standing outside, asking to speak with you.” But he said in reply to the one who told him, “Who is my mother? Who are my brothers?” And stretching out his hand toward his disciples, he said, “Here are my mother and my brothers. For whoever does the will of my heavenly Father is my brother, and sister, and mother.” (Matthew 12:46-50)

This text is often cited by non-Catholics as a counter argument against devotion to Mary. They wonder if the Catholic Church is unaware of this text, or actively ignoring it. That is far from the case! By including the text on the Marian feast day, the Church instead addresses the question head on and invites us to better understand the reasons for our belief. Jesus asks two questions, “Who is my mother? Who are my brothers?”, and the answer to each of these questions is very important!

The first question (“Who is my mother?”) seems to indicate that Jesus is downplaying the significance of Mary. The liturgy of the Church includes a response to this in the Office of Readings (part of the Liturgy of the Hours) by including a sermon from St. Augustine. St Augustine was one of the greatest teachers in the history of the Church, and served as a bishop in North Africa until 430 AD. He addresses the text by saying, “I would urge you to ponder these words. Did the Virgin Mary, who believed by faith and conceived by faith, who was the chosen one from whom our Savior was born among men, who was created by Christ before Christ was created in her – did she not do the will of the Father? Indeed the blessed Mary certainly did the Father’s will, and so it was for her a greater thing to have been Christ’s disciple than to have been his mother, and she was more blessed in her discipleship than in her motherhood.” In other words, Jesus is not minimizing Mary’s greatness in the Church, but highlighting that it comes not just from physical closeness, but the grace of God at work in her.

Augustine also uses this text to explain Mary’s role in the Church, and our own. Augustine continues, “The Virgin Mary is both holy and blessed, and yet the Church is greater than she. Mary is a part of the Church, a member of the Church, a holy, an eminent – the most eminent – member, but still only a member of the entire body. The body undoubtedly is greater than she, one of its members. This body has the Lord for its head, and head and body together make up the whole Christ. In other words, our head is divine – our head is God. Now, beloved, give me your whole attention, for you also are members of Christ; you also are the body of Christ… As for our being the brothers and sisters of Christ, we can understand this because although there is only one inheritance and Christ is the only Son, his mercy would not allow him to remain alone… You became sons when you were born there yourselves [i.e., the font of baptism], and now by bringing others to birth in the same way, you have it in your power to become the mothers of Christ.” Here Augustine affirms that Mary is the most eminent member of the Church, while clarifying Catholic teaching that we don’t worship her or put her on the same level as God. Jesus desires to truly make us His brothers and sisters through baptism, and allows us to participate spiritually in the motherhood of Mary by bringing others to birth in Christ.

Moving on to the second question Jesus asks (“Who are my brothers?”), the objection here is that it seems to indicate that Mary had children other than Jesus, while the Church holds that she did not. A key text from the tradition in response is “The Perpetual Virginity of Blessed Mary” by St Jerome, written about 383 AD. Jerome was tasked with organizing a vernacular translation of the Scriptures (Latin, at that time) and took this very seriously. He traveled to the Holy Land and lived there for years, seeking the best sources he could on the understanding of the original Hebrew and Greek texts. His conclusion was that the word for brothers (“adelphoi,” in Greek) could not be held to only indicate full-blood brothers. He gives a large sampling of texts from the Old Testament and New Testament where the word “brothers” is used to mean close kin or even the broader sense of membership in the same nation. He also provides a list of other early writers that testify to the Church’s teaching. Jerome addresses the claim that Jesus being the “first-born Son” implies that Mary had to have other children. Instead, it indicates a special significance in the Jewish faith, regardless of whether there were other sons/children. He also emphasizes that it would not have made sense for Jesus to entrust Mary to John at the Cross if she had many other children among His disciples.

Jerome wrote all this in response to Helvidius, who had written a document citing texts such as this as evidence that the Church’s belief about the Blessed Virgin Mary demonstrated a lack of familiarity with the Scriptures. Instead, Jerome argued that it was Helvidius himself who had a lack of familiarity with the Scriptures, and with the reasons for the Church’s teaching.

Returning to our starting point, it is certainly understandable that the Gospel from today’s Mass could cause confusion about Catholic teaching on Mary. Likewise, I don’t expect that everyone is familiar with the writings of St. Augustine and St. Jerome from 1600 years ago, or the history that preceded them! However, I hope that this brief summary of their main points can help to share that knowledge, and encourage authentic devotion to the Blessed Virgin Mary as lived in the Church!